Background
With-profits life insurance is a type of investment-cum-insurance product where the benefits are tied to the performance of the insurance company’s investments. Policy-holders in this type of scheme benefit from the financial gains of the insurer’s fund, receiving periodic bonuses based on the fund’s performance over a scheduled term.
Historical Context
The concept of with-profits life insurance emerged in the latter part of the 18th century as an alternative to traditional fixed-benefit life insurance policies, providing a more adaptive benefit structure relative to the financial performance of the insurer. This model gained particular traction during periods of economic growth and high inflation, when the adaptability and potential for higher returns were especially appealing to consumers.
Definitions and Concepts
- With-Profits Life Insurance: A life insurance policy where benefits to policy-holders are tied to the financial performance of the insurer’s investment fund.
- Without-Profits Life Insurance: A life insurance policy that guarantees a set amount to the policy-holder, irrespective of the financial performance of the company’s investments.
Major Analytical Frameworks
Classical Economics
Classical economics generally deals with the functioning of markets and firms, paying limited direct attention to financial products like with-profits life insurance, though it would suggest that consumer choice is driven by a desire for potentially higher returns.
Neoclassical Economics
Neoclassical economics would analyze with-profits life insurance under the standard utility-maximization framework, where individuals choose their policies based on factors like risk tolerance and expected utility from potential gains versus certain but fixed returns in without-profits life insurance.
Keynesian Economics
Keynesian economics would be more concerned with how these types of investments and insurance policies affect overall consumption patterns, savings rates, and economic stability, noting the aggregate demand implications of changes in household wealth due to with-profits bonuses.
Marxian Economics
Marxian economists might critique with-profits life insurance for potentially showcasing the dynamics of financial capitalism — where wealthy insurers reap the main benefits of investments, rather than the working class who primarily hold these policies for security.
Institutional Economics
Institutional economics would consider the role of regulatory frameworks, insurance company behaviors, and historical developments affecting the popularity and design of with-profits life insurance policies.
Behavioral Economics
Behavioral economics might delve into why individuals choose with-profits life insurance over other types, focusing on aspects such as financial literacy, the impact of guaranteed returns versus potential higher gains, and psychological factors influencing risk perceptions.
Post-Keynesian Economics
Post-Keynesians might focus on the financial stability aspects of these policies, emphasizing how risk-sharing between insurers and policyholders could affect branched economic facets like capital markets and broader economic stability.
Austrian Economics
Austrian economists, focusing on individual choice and free-market principles, would be interested in how consumer valuations of risk and returns shape the lifecycle choices concerning insurance products.
Development Economics
Development economists might look at how insurance products, including with-profits life insurance, affect financial inclusion and economic security in developing nations.
Monetarism
Monetarists would consider the impact of these investment-centric insurance policies on the money supply and overall inflation, noting how performance-based returns could provide a hedge against inflationary risks.
Comparative Analysis
- Risk and Returns: With-profits policies present a higher potential return tied to investment performance, but also come with more variability. Without-profits policies offer guaranteed returns with no investment risk, making them more stable but less adaptable to inflation.
- Insurance Cost: Premiums for with-profits life insurance are generally less than without-profits life insurance for the same expected benefits at maturity due to the inherent risk-sharing feature.
- Inflation Protection: With-profits policies provide better protection against inflation over the policy term compared to without-profits policies, which can be an overriding consideration during periods of high inflation.
Case Studies
Examining historical performance during different economic periods can illuminate the relative benefits and drawbacks of with-profits policies. For instance, policies issued during high-growth periods might show higher bonuses, while those initiated during recessions might exhibit limited benefits.
Suggested Books for Further Studies
- The Economics of Life Insurance by J. David Cummins
- Insurance and Investment Management Mergers & Acquisitions by James S. Wimsatt
- Life Insurance 15th (fifteenth) edition by Kenneth Black Jr., Harold D. Skipper Jr.
Related Terms with Definitions
- Premium: The amount of money paid periodically by the policy-holder to the insurer for covering risk.
- Bonus: A discretionary addition made by the insurer to the policy’s sum assured, dependent on the performance of the
